I apologise for the quite awful play on words but it was too
good not to write! In this post I want to talk about a couple of things; one:
Katie McGarry’s fantastic book ‘Pushing the Limits’ as well as the issues
surrounding it and the newly popular YA genre named ‘sick-lit’.
I don’t want to scare anyone away from reading ‘Pushing the
Limits’ by associating it with the topic of ‘sick-lit’ as it does sound a bit
scary – my premise being that ‘PTL’ does not (thankfully) fall under this
genre, and in fact takes troubling issues and makes them approachable and
acceptable through the powerful relationship between the two main characters
Echo and Noah.
I’ll backtrack a little and give you the quick synopsis of
PTL incase you haven’t read it yet *no spoilers*:
“No one knows what happened the night Echo
Emerson went from popular girl with jock boyfriend to gossiped-about outsider
with "freaky" scars on her arms. Even Echo can't remember the whole
truth of that horrible night. All she knows is that she wants everything to go
back to normal. But when Noah Hutchins, the smoking-hot, girl-using loner in
the black leather jacket, explodes into her life with his tough attitude and
surprising understanding, Echo's world shifts in ways she could never have
imagined. They should have nothing in common. And with the secrets they both
keep, being together is pretty much impossible. Yet the crazy attraction between them refuses to go away. And Echo has
to ask herself just how far they can push the limits and what she'll risk for
the one guy who might teach her how to love again.”
Exploring the
issues of ‘troubled’ and ‘traumatised’ teens, ‘Pushing the Limits’ is such a
great read because it shows how these things are okay and that you don’t have
to be alone with them. Unfortunately there are teenagers out there who have to
struggle with dysfunctional families, mental health, loss, foster homes as well
as a social status, but ‘PTL’ makes you feel like you’re not traveling alone
and that there is someone, lots of people out there who want to stick by you
and support you through it, be it family, teachers, authority or friends. Echo
and Noah are thrown together by therapy sessions, rather begrudgingly, but it
is after they start to get to know each other and see the real characters under
all the trouble and defences do they begin to realise how much they need each other.
Although their problems are completely different, they mould together to try
find the solutions and start to gradually work their way back into feeling good
about the world again. It is a relatable story, even for those without anything
in common with the characters, which makes it such easy reading.
Whilst ‘Pushing
the Limits’ finds a level balance between portraying issues that teens
may suffer and the positive outcomes of it (i.e. bringing people together,
enjoying life, making friends, falling in love etc.), some books have started
to make more of an extreme statement with a negative effect. I was pointed
towards an article the other day that honestly left me horrified. The new YA
fiction trend is apparently ‘sick-lit’. Publishers are publishing a large
amount of books for teenagers, even younger teens, that talk of terminally ill
characters, suicide, depression, self-harm and death. Books that will leave
their readers ‘devastated’ but “inadvertently glamourise”* these issues. These
stories describe the feelings and effects of these issues so much that they
quite often become seen as more like an instruction book than a fictional
story. One book about self-harming is meant to have sparked some reaction in
some readers to actually start self-harming themselves as a ‘comfort’ as the
story was “too close to home”. I don’t want to make rash judgements about these
books without having read them myself or got reader reactions beforehand, but
it just strikes me as something going very wrong here, publishers are making it a 'trend' rather than a delicate issue? If teens as young as 12
and 13 are reading these books? I think as genre trends go within fiction, as
much as I have my own opinions on the likes of the Twilight fandom and 50
Shades of Grey trend, I think ‘sick-lit’ is something that shouldn’t be
encouraged in the way that it seems to be. It is fantastic that there are ways these issues that can be approached and talked about through fiction that a reader
may not feel comfortable sharing or dealing with in real life, but I would say
it still needs to be done delicately in what is being promoted. I'm not saying let's cover up the harsh realities of it, but maybe the portrayal of this 'trend' need to be re-issued? Pushing the
Limits does this excellently, the biggest message that I picked up from it is
that you don’t need to hide away, by letting yourself be supported you can pick
up the pieces and start to rebuild your life in the way you want it to. Even if
your body isn’t letting you, like Echo’s, when you’re ready it will come.
On a slightly more cheery note (I promise the next post will
be full of sunshine and rainbows, figuratively). If you want to read ‘Pushing
the Limits’, which you all do straight away(!), you can buy the book or it is
currently storming through at number one in the Kindle charts at only 20p! It
would be rude not to read it now!
Please also tell me what you think of both ‘Pushing the
Limits’ and also the issues on sick-lit. Do you agree with what I think, or do
you think it is an exaggeration and not something that should be worried about?
All comments welcome.
Have a great week!
Emily x
*I know that the Daily Mail doesn't have much credibility in terms of hard facts, but it was the article I had that could be linked on here.
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-2256356/The-sick-lit-books-aimed-children-Its-disturbing-phenomenon-Tales-teenage-cancer-self-harm-suicide-.html
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-2256356/The-sick-lit-books-aimed-children-Its-disturbing-phenomenon-Tales-teenage-cancer-self-harm-suicide-.html